top of page
Search

Grade Inflation

2 hours ago
10 min read

If you've been to the grocery store lately, filled up your gas tank, or paid just about any household bill, you've probably noticed that your money doesn't go nearly as far as it used to. Economists call this inflation. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks it through the Consumer Price Index, which measures changes in the prices consumers pay for everyday goods and services.


Unfortunately, it seems that inflation isn't limited to the economy. Grades may be experiencing a little inflation of their own.


An A was intended to signify exceptional academic performance. A C generally meant that a student was doing average work. Today, in many schools, A's seem to be everywhere. In some classrooms, receiving anything less than an A can feel like a disappointment rather than a reflection of perfectly respectable academic achievement.


So, what happened? Have students become dramatically better learners? Are teachers doing a better job? Have schools figured out how to help more students succeed? Or have we gradually changed what it means to earn an A?


This is the issue commonly referred to as grade inflation: the tendency for grades to increase over time without a corresponding improvement in demonstrated academic achievement.


It's an especially interesting issue when we consider high school Advanced Placement courses. AP Biology, AP Chemistry, AP Physics, and AP Environmental Science are supposed to challenge students with college-level material. If nearly everyone is earning an A, does that mean nearly everyone is mastering the material, or have we quietly lowered the bar?

It's a question worth asking.


What Is an A Actually Supposed to Mean?

Most of us grew up with the familiar A–B–C–D–F grading system. It seems straightforward enough:

Grade

Typical percentage

Traditional meaning

GPA

A

90–100

Excellent

4.0

B

80–89

Good

3.0

C

70–79

Average

2.0

D

60–69

Below average

1.0

F

Below 60

Failing

0.0


Of course, schools use different grading scales, and these percentages are not national requirements. Still, the general idea has been familiar to generations of American students.

The modern letter-grading system developed gradually during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. By the middle of the twentieth century, it had become a familiar feature of American education (Schneider & Hutt, 2013).


The original purpose was to communicate how well a student understood the material. An A represented excellent work, a B represented good work, and a C indicated satisfactory or average performance.


That raises an interesting question. If an entire class earns A's, is that a sign of excellent teaching and student learning, or is it a sign that the grading standards have changed?

The answer, of course, could be either. A teacher who helps nearly every student master challenging material should be celebrated, not criticized. The problem arises when grades increase without convincing evidence that students are learning more.


The Bell Curve: Does Everyone Deserve an A?

Anyone who has taken a statistics course has probably encountered the bell curve, or normal distribution. It is sometimes used to describe how student performance is distributed within a class.


Imagine a class in which grades are distributed as follows:

Grade

Hypothetical percentage of students

A

10%

B

20%

C

40%

D

20%

F

10%


This is an illustration, not a required grading distribution.


The traditional bell-curve approach is associated with norm-referenced grading. Students are compared with one another, and grades reflect their relative performance.


There is another approach, however, that makes considerably more sense when evaluating whether students have actually learned something: criterion-referenced grading.


With criterion-referenced grading, students are evaluated against established expectations. If everyone in an AP Biology class demonstrates exceptional understanding of genetics, cellular processes, and experimental design, everyone should be eligible for an A. There is no reason to artificially assign lower grades just to create a bell curve.


This distinction matters. A bell curve should not determine how many students succeed or fail.


In fact, Benjamin Bloom (1968) challenged the traditional assumption that only a small percentage of students could achieve high levels of academic performance. His work on mastery learning suggested that with appropriate instruction, feedback, and sufficient time, many more students could master challenging material.


I think this is an important point for teachers. The goal shouldn't be to limit the number of A's. The goal should be to make sure an A actually means something.


A Look Back: How Have Grades Changed Since the 1950s?

Grade inflation is hardly a new complaint. Educators have been debating the value of grades for generations. Interestingly, concerns about overly generous grades were being raised at Harvard as far back as the nineteenth century (Schinske & Tanner, 2014).

But what has actually happened to high school grades over the past seventy years?


Unfortunately, finding a consistent answer isn't easy. There isn't a single national database tracking average high school GPAs all the way back to 1950. The more reliable national transcript studies begin much later.


Still, the available research gives us a pretty interesting picture.


The historical record

Year

Average GPA

Source

1950

Not available

No comparable national data

1960

Not available

No comparable national data

1972

2.78

National high school study

1980

2.85

National high school study

1990

2.68

NCES transcript study

1994

2.79

NCES transcript study

1998

2.90

NCES transcript study

2000

2.94

NCES transcript study

2009

3.00

NCES transcript study

2010

3.22

ACT-tested graduates

2020

3.37

ACT-tested graduates

2021

3.39

ACT-tested graduates

Note: These figures come from different studies and populations and should not be interpreted as one continuous statistical series. The 1950s and 1960s figures are unavailable, rather than zero.


The 1970s: The beginning of measurable change

One particularly interesting study compared high school seniors graduating in 1972 and 1980.


Fetters, Brown, and Owings (1984) found that average high school GPA increased from 2.78 to 2.85. Even more interesting, the percentage of students receiving predominantly A grades increased from 8.9% to 11.8%.


That represents roughly a one-third increase in the proportion of students earning mostly A's in just eight years.


While the increase might not sound enormous, it is worth remembering that this was happening decades before today's emphasis on weighted GPAs, college admissions competition, and the pressure to build an impressive academic transcript.


The 1990s and 2000s: The upward trend continues

National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) transcript data show that average high school GPA increased from 2.68 in 1990 to 3.00 in 2009.


The changes weren't limited to overall GPA, either. Between 1990 and 2000, average science GPA increased from 2.39 to 2.67. Mathematics GPA increased from 2.34 to 2.60 (NCES, 2004).

These findings are particularly interesting for anyone teaching science or mathematics.


These are subjects in which students are expected to demonstrate problem-solving skills, conceptual understanding, and the ability to apply what they have learned.


Of course, higher grades don't automatically mean that academic standards have declined. Students may have benefited from better instruction, improved resources, and greater access to advanced coursework. But the increases certainly deserve attention.


The 2010s and 2020: When the numbers become especially interesting

Perhaps the most compelling recent research comes from ACT researchers Edgar Sanchez and Raeal Moore (2022).


Their study examined more than four million ACT-tested high school graduates between 2010 and 2021.


Here are some of their findings:

Measure

2010

2020

2021

Average high school GPA

3.22

3.37

3.39

Average ACT Composite

21.0

20.6

20.3

Students earning an A average

40.3%

52.6%

54.9%

Students earning a B average

46.8%

38.1%

36.2%

Students earning a C average

12.0%

8.4%

8.1%

Source: Sanchez and Moore (2022). These figures represent ACT-tested graduates, not all American high school students.


Now, this is where things get interesting.


Between 2010 and 2021, the percentage of students reporting an A average increased from 40.3% to 54.9%. At the same time, average ACT Composite scores declined from 21.0 to 20.3.


In other words, more students were earning A averages, but standardized test performance wasn't increasing along with those grades.


Does this prove that every school is inflating grades? Absolutely not. ACT scores and classroom grades measure different things, and the students taking the ACT are not necessarily representative of every high school student.


Still, the findings raise a legitimate question: Are we becoming more successful at teaching students, or are we simply becoming more generous with grades?


That question became even more relevant during the COVID-19 pandemic, when many schools modified grading policies, offered additional opportunities for students to complete work, and adjusted academic expectations.


What About AP Science Courses?

This is where the conversation becomes especially relevant to high school science teachers.

AP courses are intended to provide students with a college-level academic experience. AP Biology, Chemistry, Environmental Science, and Physics require much more than memorizing vocabulary and completing worksheets.


Students are expected to interpret experimental data, understand scientific models, evaluate evidence, solve problems, and apply concepts to unfamiliar situations.


An AP Biology student should be able to analyze experimental results and explain biological processes. An AP Chemistry student should understand why chemical reactions occur, not simply memorize equations. An AP Physics student should be able to apply physical principles to problems that may look very different from those practiced in class.


These are demanding expectations. And they should be.


Consider a hypothetical situation: A student earns an A in AP Chemistry but receives a 2 on the AP examination.


Is that evidence of grade inflation?


Not necessarily. Classroom grades reflect an entire year of work, including laboratories, projects, homework, quizzes, and tests. The AP examination is a standardized assessment administered under different conditions.


There are legitimate reasons why the two measures might differ.


However, if a school consistently sees students earning A's in AP science courses while a relatively small proportion demonstrate proficiency on external assessments, it may be time to examine the grading practices.


What do AP examination results tell us?

The College Board publishes annual AP examination score distributions. These provide another way to examine student achievement in advanced science courses.


For context, the following table shows selected AP science examination results from 2025:

AP science course

Percentage earning a 3 or higher

AP Biology

70.4%

AP Chemistry

77.9%

AP Environmental Science

69.2%

AP Physics 1

67.3%

Source: College Board, 2025 AP Score Distributions.


These results demonstrate that substantial numbers of students are successfully completing challenging AP science examinations.


However, there is an important distinction: An AP score of 3, 4, or 5 is not equivalent to a classroom grade of C, B, or A. The two systems measure different things.


The real value of these examination results is that they give schools an additional source of information. When classroom grades and AP examination performance are considered together, educators can begin to identify possible gaps between what students are earning and what they can independently demonstrate.


Perhaps this is a conversation every AP science department should be having.


Why Are Grades Increasing?

There probably isn't one simple explanation. Several factors may be contributing to the increase in grades.


College admissions pressure

College admissions have become increasingly competitive. Students and parents understand that GPA can have a significant impact on college opportunities. That creates pressure on teachers and schools to maintain high grades.


Weighted GPAs

AP and honors courses often receive additional GPA points. Although this is intended to reward students for taking more challenging classes, it can also make GPA comparisons between schools more complicated.


Retakes and extra credit

Allowing students to retake assessments, correct mistakes, and improve their understanding can be excellent teaching practices. The problem arises when grades become a reflection of accumulated points rather than demonstrated mastery.


Parent and student expectations

In some schools, anything less than an A can lead to questions, meetings, and discussions about grading policies. Teachers may find themselves defending grades that accurately reflect student performance.


Inconsistent grading standards

Two teachers teaching the same AP course may have very different ideas about what constitutes an A. Without common assessments or shared expectations, grades may mean different things even within the same school.


None of these factors necessarily causes grade inflation by itself. However, together they can create an environment in which maintaining high GPAs becomes more important than accurately communicating academic achievement.


What Can We Do About It?

I don't think the answer is to make AP science courses harder simply for the sake of making them harder. Nor should teachers be expected to follow a bell curve and limit the number of students receiving A's.


If every student genuinely demonstrates mastery, every student deserves the grade.

What we should be doing is making sure that our grading practices reflect what students actually know and can do.


A few practical steps would help:

  • Align classroom assessments with the College Board's AP course frameworks.

  • Use common assessments and grading rubrics among teachers teaching the same course.

  • Include AP-style multiple-choice and free-response questions throughout the year.

  • Require students to interpret unfamiliar data and explain scientific reasoning.

  • Compare classroom grades with AP examination results and other measures of achievement.

  • Make retakes and corrections opportunities for learning, while ensuring final grades still reflect independent understanding.

  • Evaluate whether students can apply concepts to new situations rather than simply reproduce material from class notes.


Most importantly, we need to remember that rigor and support are not opposites. Students can be challenged, supported, and successful at the same time.


The goal should be to help more students reach high levels of achievement, not to lower the meaning of achievement itself.


Final Thoughts: What Is an A Really Worth?

Economic inflation reduces the purchasing power of money. Grade inflation, when it occurs, can reduce the value of something just as important: the information communicated by a student's academic record.


The research suggests that high school grades have generally increased over the past several decades. ACT findings are particularly interesting because they show that the percentage of students reporting A averages has increased even as average ACT scores have declined.


The evidence specific to science is also worth considering. ACT research has found increases in science GPAs without corresponding improvements in ACT science performance.


These findings don't mean that today's students are less capable, that teachers are doing a worse job, or that schools should start handing out fewer A's. They do mean that we should take a closer look at what our grades actually represent.


An A in AP Biology, Chemistry, Physics, or Environmental Science should reflect a student's ability to understand scientific concepts, interpret evidence, solve problems, and apply knowledge independently.


Students who achieve that level of understanding deserve their A's, whether there are two of them in the classroom or twenty.


But an A should not simply be a reward for completing assignments, accumulating points, or negotiating a better grade.


Perhaps the question we should be asking is not how many students are getting A's, but whether those students have actually mastered the material.


And if we're going to keep inflating something in this country, perhaps it would be better to inflate scientific literacy rather than GPAs.


After all, the real measure of an AP science course isn't the number of A's on the report card. It's what students can actually do with what they've learned.


References

ACT. (2022). Grade inflation continues to grow in the past decade. ACT Research Report R2134. ACT, Inc. https://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/2022/R2134-Grade-Inflation-Continues-to-Grow-in-the-Past-Decade-Final-Accessible.pdf


Bloom, B. S. (1968). Learning for mastery. Evaluation Comment, 1(2), 1–12. UCLA Center for the Study of Evaluation. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED053419.pdf


Bureau of Labor Statistics. (n.d.). Consumer Price Index: Frequently asked questions. U.S. Department of Labor. https://www.bls.gov/cpi/questions-and-answers.htm


College Board. (2025). 2025 AP score distributions. https://apstudents.collegeboard.org/about-ap-scores/score-distributions/2025


Fetters, W. B., Brown, G. H., & Owings, J. A. (1984). High school seniors: A comparative study of the classes of 1972 and 1980. National Center for Education Statistics. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED248277.pdf


National Center for Education Statistics. (2004). The high school transcript study: A decade of change in curricula and achievement, 1990–2000. U.S. Department of Education. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2004/2004455_b.pdf


National Center for Education Statistics. (n.d.). High school transcript studies. Institute of Education Sciences. https://nces.ed.gov/use-work/elementarysecondary/hst-high-school-transcript-studies


Pattison, E., Grodsky, E., & Muller, C. (2013). Is the sky falling? Grade inflation and the signaling power of grades. Educational Researcher, 42(5), 259–265. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X13481382


Schinske, J., & Tanner, K. (2014). Teaching more by grading less (or differently). CBE—Life Sciences Education, 13(2), 159–166. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.CBE-14-03-0054


Schneider, J., & Hutt, E. (2013). Making the grade: A history of the A–F marking scheme. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 46(2), 201–224. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220272.2013.790480

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page